Extra Geography is Molly Manners’ standout debut feature film as part of this year’s British Film Festival, first premiering at Sundance Film Festival and featuring outstanding Swiss-watch precision performances by breakout actresses Galaxie Clear and Marnie Duggan alongside Alice Englert and Aoife Riddell.
I’ll raise my hand with a confession, Miss.
I didn’t want to watch this film when I first read the synopsis:
Two teenage girls, bored with the mundanity of private boarding school life, conspire to set themselves a summer challenge and compete to experience love by winning the affections of their reclusive geography teacher. One, devoted to the other, fears losing her approval if she slips up.

Sounds nasty. Too reminiscent of what I remember fifteen year olds being like in my school days.
In fact, it is uncanny how aptly this film captures coming of age in all its awkward, anxious, messy unfolding.
Extra Geography excels in deadpan devastating blunt earnestness. The girls are a scream, batting ruthless unfiltered absurd observations and conclusions back and forth at each other, fiercely calibrated to their own naive wavelength with minimal regard for outside opinion. Their chronic self awareness deficit isn’t helped from living in a perfect microcosm of female teenage angst, in an environment that primes them to endlessly and often unconsciously compete with each other under intense peer pressure. The slightest of trivialities are afforded the greatest gravity, made even funnier by their obliviousness of social norms, or others’ feelings.
The girls tolerate it all in the name of building their future and making it someday to the guilded “Oxbridge”. They don’t know what they want after that point. They have no idea what they’ll do. Or what constitutes an “important” pursuit. Only that studying is akin to godliness, prestige is everything, and mediocrity simply will not do.
There are ripples in this arrangement where it is quietly clear that self conscious, apologetic, dedicated Flic is emulating Minna’s mannerisms and dogmatically pretending to be in sync just to avoid even the faintest possibility of rocking the boat. Perhaps Mina has an inkling of this and likes this exactly the way it is?
Galaxie Clear (Minna) and Marni Duggan (Flic) inhabit their roles on the screen with utterly perfect chemistry. Clear radiates effortless self confidence and Duggan smoulders in her shadow. They are endearing and hearfelt, while simultaneously behaving as entitled brats. You believe that they have known each other for years, that they are inseparable, and are completely convinced that this alone is the most important part of their lives and the world will simply end if it doesn’t go exactly to plan.
Amidst their urgent, thoughtless calculations, Extra Geography is a delight to watch. The North Yorkshire setting with the grand limestone presence of Gilling Castle portrayed here as a boarding school carries a weight of history but feels fresh rather than too pompous or stuffy, a critical detail given the number of interior scenes. Vibrant luscious colour and gentle warm lighting feels almost jarring against the severity of their treatment of their cohorts, and each other.
It is impossible not to squirm and groan as the girls’ antics ramp up, competing with each other to be noticed, not just by Miss Delavigne, but later also by the boys of a neighbouring private school jointly participating in this year’s school play: A Midsummer Night’s Dream. And alas, here is their chance to make their mark. Surely performing well in this play would gain them extra social credit and increase their chances of university admission?
Strangely, Minna seems less interested in capitalising on her opportunity in a leading role, and on completing their “summer project”, than she does in gaining the boys’ attention.
Arthur Sharpe’s score in Extra Geography dangles tension nicely throughout the four act of the film, blending indie rock with classic, amplifying through strings and carrying the dread of heartbreak for agonisingly prolonged sequences. The atmosphere is complete with a cameo look in by Belle and Sebastian’s “Wrapped Up in Books”, to the delight of anyone who hailed from Scotland in the 1990s.
Extra Geography is sharply funny, extremely relatable, and cynical. It hurts and entertains all at once. This is a timeless entry adapted from a short story set in the 1950s that easily still strikes a chord in 2026.
9/10
Extra Geography is showing now at Luna Cinemas as part of the British Film Festival 28 October – 6 December 2026.

*By Gayle O’Leary. If you’d like to catch up on more by Gayle here on Fremantle Shipping News, look right here!
~ If you’d like to COMMENT on this or any of our stories, don’t hesitate to email our Editor.
~ WHILE YOU’RE HERE –
PLEASE HELP US TO GROW FREMANTLE SHIPPING NEWS
FSN is a reader-supported, volunteer-assisted online magazine all about Fremantle. Thanks for helping to keep FSN keeping on!







